Knicks Collapse in Overtime as Pacers Pull Off Historic Game 1 Comeback

Graphic showing Knicks losing to Pacers 138-135 in overtime during Game 1 on May 21, 2025, with team jerseys and final score.

The New York Knicks suffered a devastating loss in Game 1 of the 2025 NBA Playoffs, falling 138–135 to the Indiana Pacers in an electrifying overtime thriller at Madison Square Garden. With under three minutes to play, the Knicks held a 14-point lead and appeared poised for victory. But a late-game meltdown allowed the Pacers to storm back, turning what looked like a sure win into one of the most shocking collapses in playoff history.

Jalen Brunson Shines, But Knicks Fall Short

Jalen Brunson was sensational, pouring in 43 points on an efficient 15-of-25 shooting night. Karl-Anthony Towns also had a dominant outing, recording 35 points and 12 rebounds. Despite these standout performances, the Knicks couldn’t close the door in the final minutes of regulation.

Aaron Nesmith and Tyrese Haliburton Lead Furious Pacers Rally

Indiana’s Aaron Nesmith sparked the comeback with a historic three-point shooting spree—drilling six three-pointers in the fourth quarter alone, tying an NBA playoff record for the most made threes in a single quarter. Tyrese Haliburton added 31 points and 11 assists, including a dramatic game-tying jumper as the buzzer sounded to force overtime.

Obi Toppin Haunts Former Team in Overtime

In the extra period, it was former Knick Obi Toppin who delivered the dagger. Toppin slammed home two critical dunks, energizing the Pacers and crushing New York’s hopes. The Knicks had chances to even the score but failed to capitalize, missing several key shots down the stretch.

A Collapse for the Record Books

This defeat will be remembered as one of the most heartbreaking collapses in NBA postseason history. Statistically, teams leading by 14 points with under three minutes remaining had won 99.7% of those games. The Knicks' inability to secure the win places them on the wrong side of an incredibly rare and painful statistic.

What’s Next: Game 2 at the Garden

Game 2 is set for Friday night at Madison Square Garden. The Knicks must regroup both mentally and strategically to prevent Indiana from seizing full control of the series. Expect Coach Tom Thibodeau to make adjustments and demand a more disciplined finish from his team.